Interests:Reading, writing, philosophy, history, computer games, genre fiction, web programming
Affiliation:Libertarian
Religion:None
Reputation: -29
Bad
Posted 28 April 2006 - 03:20 PM
I have some... ahem, pointed... musings about the third season finale of The X-Files, "Talitha Cumi" (or however one spells it):
Spoiler
The ultimate weapon for killing the aliens is... a pointy metal stick. As if that's not absurd enough, the government is willing to kill Agent Fox Mulder for the pointy metal stick he recovered from his parents' summer home. Why doesn't the government simply make pointy metal sticks of its own? I could understand the government's urgency if the stick were made out of a rare extraterrestrial ore, but the episode doesn't indicate it is. It just seems to be an earthly pointy metal stick.
Here's how the confrontation between X and Mulder should have transpired:
Quote
X: Give me what you found at the house.
Mulder: No, mine! Get your own pointy metal stick.
X: I can't. Just give me yours.
Mulder: The government of the United States, the sole remaining superpower on Earth, with the ability to put a man on the Moon and drive a global conspiracy of silence regarding the existence of extraterrestrials, can't make its own pointy metal sticks?
X: You idiot, we can't make them with sheet metal from Sears!
The episode was cool, but the lunacy of the pointy metal stick niggled at my mind throughout the whole thing.
"People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people." -V for Vendetta
Yes that's true. I think it didn't bother me when I watched that episode a couple of years ago because I simply assumed this metal stick must be somehow special.
So -- I assume you have seen the entire season 3 so far. What do you think of it and which are your favourite episodes?
"In earlier religions the spirit of the time was expressed through the individual and confirmed by miracles. In modern religions the spirit is expressed through the many and confirmed by reason."
"Wherever they burn books they will also, in the end, burn human beings."
Interests:Reading, writing, philosophy, history, computer games, genre fiction, web programming
Affiliation:Libertarian
Religion:None
Reputation: -29
Bad
Posted 04 May 2006 - 02:03 PM
Season three was fantastic; full of suspense and humor, it was probably the best X-Files season. My favorite episode was "War of the Caprophages," which combined a fascinating sci-fi premise with clever hilarity.
"People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people." -V for Vendetta
Interests:Reading, writing, philosophy, history, computer games, genre fiction, web programming
Affiliation:Libertarian
Religion:None
Reputation: -29
Bad
Posted 05 May 2006 - 09:50 PM
Okay, what the hell? I watched the fourth season premiere, "Herrenvolk," tonight, and...
Spoiler
After all the brouhaha over the special pointy metal stick, Mulder sticks it into the back of the alien bounty hunter's neck, and the son of a bitch doesn't die. We don't even get an explanation as to why. That's a letdown.
Also, Scully doesn't seem to recognize the bounty hunter as the same being who captured her in season two. Otherwise, she wouldn't have called him "sir" in a neutral voice, and she wouldn't have uselessly threatened him with a gun.
The episode was okay, but these logical deficiencies dragged it down a lot.
"People should not be afraid of their governments. Governments should be afraid of their people." -V for Vendetta